I'm not a huge fan of the film Se7en.
I don't mind it, but it's not something
I'm too likely to go "Hey, I want
to watch Se7en again!"
and skip on down to the video store to get. Yeah,
it's well made, very atmospheric and the
performances turned in by pretty much all the
cast members are good, it's just one of
those films that for me, once or twice is really
enough. But I do love my comic books however,
and am always interested in seeing what comic
book creators can do with cinematic licenses,
particularly if they're ones you know can
lend themselves to some interesting creative license
on behalf of the writer or artist, or are ideas
that would simply make awesome comics. Needless
to say, when I read in Previews a few months back
that new comer indie comic book publisher Zenoscope
Entertainment would be releasing the first in
a series of comics based on Se7en,
my curiosity piqued.
Fast forward a couple of months, and when the
book hit the shelves I made sure it was in my
bloodthirsty hands as soon as possible. Having
stood well clear of any and all spoiler material
that was floating around the internet leading
up to the release, I really wasn't sure
what to expect of the book. It had a cover that
was very much in the IDW vein (great art too,
perfectly capturing the visual feel of the film's
inspiring opening credits), and upon the customary
flip through, saw that the interior art was largely
painted and included some pages similar to the
cover (cross-media digital works). So far, so
good. What followed was something that took me
pretty much off guard, going against all my expectations
of this comic.
Gluttony is told from a dual
point perspective. The majority is told through
the interior monologues of the film's killer
Jonathon Doe (get it, John Doe… of course
you did, I'm sorry…) relaying and
expanding upon his reasoning and motivations evident
in the film. It reads much like the confessions
of a serial killer. You get an extremely insightful
look into the way this man works, without being
repulsed or growing at all attached to the character.
You feel somewhat cold to him because of what
he is, but you want to stay with it because there's
an innate and perverse interest in wanting to
know why he is that way. Relative newcomer Raven
Gregory (writer and creator of Image Comic's
The Gift) manages to capture
Kevin Spacey's performance and character
perfectly in his words and you can hear John Doe
so perfectly as you read it. The dialogue of the
Doe character also contrasts rather well with
the much more tragic and nameless victim.
What this comic does is show us the events leading
up to the murders, through the eyes of both the
killer and the victim, and in the case of Gluttony,
the circumstances couldn't be more tragic.
The victim hates himself. To say he's had
it hard in life is an understatement, and because
of this, his depression and level of self worth
causes him to eat in excess, wanting to fill the
emptiness in his life. The guy genuinely hates
the way he is and wants to do something about
it and is actually on the verge of turning over
a new leaf when Doe gets to him. Just as Doe's
interior dialogue suited him perfectly, the inner
thoughts of the victim juxtapose Doe, providing
the perfect counterbalance to the book and giving
readers some emotional anchor – even though
we know perfectly well where things are going.
Where Doe is educated, well spoken and extremely
cold, the victim is very much the opposite. His
dialogue is fairly colloquial and quite easy to
read and makes him very easy to empathise with,
and though it isn't as intelligent as the
writing in Doe's interiors from a character
perspective, it does highlight that Gregory is
a versatile writer, able to identify with particular
and differing characters with ease and present
them in very distinct ways, which makes me look
forward to the character portrayals of other victims
in the following issues (assuming Gregory is the
writer behind the subsequent issues).
Tommy Castillo's art is what took me most
by surprise. It took me a little while to warm
to it, as it's not as realistic as I was
expecting and slightly lessens that sense of grit
that Fincher gave to the film (and is a notable
style inherent in most of his other features).
There's a slightly cartoonish element to
the book which, while it works, kind of makes
me feel as though a more realistic approach would
have been more affecting to the reader. Se7en
was a pretty heavy film, and the murders themselves
probably more so, so it's a little detracting
when you giggle a little at one of the more brutal
moments in the book simply because it looks kinda
funny. Still, his chosen angles for the panels
suit the book perfectly and manage to retain a
fairly cinematic feel to them, while also remaining
distinctly artistic in their own right. The use
of lighting and shading is also particularly notable,
and manages to translate that sense of mystery
over who John Doe was in the film to the pages
of this book really well. The colours by Mark
McNabb are also great, giving the whole book a
painted feel as well as that washed out, desaturated
tone that was so prominent in the film (and once
again, throughout most of Fincher's films).
As I said at the beginning, I'm not a big
fan of the film, and was somewhat ho-hum about
the book (but interested nonetheless), but having
read it, and being pleasantly surprised, I'm
sure that fans of the film will love this comic,
and the $3.99 U.S. pricetag (about $7 AU) isn't
going to put that much of a dent in your wallet.
Those new or indifferent to the film may want
to have a flip though before deciding. |