| Cover Art |
 |
| Credits |
Director: Stanley Kubrick
Starring: Jack Nicholson, Shelley Duvall, Danny Lloyd, Scatman Crothers
Screenplay: Stanley Kubrick, Diane Johnson
Country: UK/USA |
I've seen many horror films. From the seminal likes of The Exorcist and Dawn of the Dead, to the classic exploitationers Cannibal Holocaust and Maniac, horror is most definitely my preferred genre.
And The Shining is my favourite horror film of all time.
A bold claim to make, sure – especially given the names 'Kubrick' and 'Nicholson' don't ring true in the genre, But not only does The Shining chop off the neck and piss down the trunk of its source material, the deliciously pulpy Stephen King novel of the same name, but it stands head-and-shoulders above every other horror film ever made.
The Shining introduces Jack Torrance, who is played by Jack Nicholson in one of the best performances I have ever seen from any actor ever. Torrance, a recovering alcoholic and struggling writer, applies for the job of winter caretaker for the remote Overlook Hotel, which remains totally snowbound for the duration of the season. The hotel's manager tells Torrance of the past caretaker who, after suffering from a particularly nasty bout of cabin fever, killed his wife and two young daughters, before putting his shotgun into his own mouth. This doesn't deter Torrance and, eager to cure his writer's block, packs up his own wife Wendy (Shelley Duvall) and eight-year-old son Danny (Lloyd). However before the move, Danny has a horrific vision of murder and mayhem. This is caused by Danny's ability to 'shine', a vague blend of seeing into the past and into the future. Wendy tells Jack that Danny has an imaginary friend 'Tony', and that the change of environment may act to the family's detriment, but Torrance pays no attention.
At the Overlook, the Torrance's are welcomed by the head chef Dick Halloran (Scatman Crothers). Halloran possesses a similar intuitive gift as Danny and attempts to counsel the youngster, finally warning him to 'stay out of Room 237'. Ill-at-ease, Halloran nevertheless goes ahead with his plans and heads down to his Florida winter home, leaving the family. However, Danny's visions begin to become stronger and far more fearsome, with the menacing promise of destruction. Jack, too, begins to have frightening hallucinations; a ballroom filled with people and an encounter with the occupant of Room 237. With the writer's block becoming overbearing and the cabin fever creeping into him insidiously, Jack finally snaps...
Stanley Kubrick describes King's The Shining as the 'only thing ever sent to me that I ever liked', and backhandedly compliments the author by alleging that he 'doesn't seem interested in writing itself... [Invention] is his forte'. King himself expressed disdain over the film adaptation – Kubrick dismissed many of his initial ideas, including an entire screenplay, and the author later likened the completed film to 'a shiny Rolls-Royce with nothing under the hood'. So ridiculously ill-conceived were his comments that King presumably felt obligated to retract them, saying 'I used to think that books outlived movies, but I'm not sure that one's done it'.
And it hadn't. While King spun an entertaining horror yarn with his 1977 bestseller, Kubrick turned it into an absolute masterwork. The screenplay, written by Kubrick and Diane Johnson, derives superficially from King's work and adds an extra dimension of terror to it, an exploration of the psychological and psychosexual that the author has never fully achieved with any part of his oeuvre. The Shining is a phenomenal work of film, and Kubrick so intriguingly and profoundly delves into the mind of a madman that you feel implicated in his actions, from when Jack verbally abuses Wendy, to the infamous axe-through-the-door sequence that made Nicholson a cult icon (I even own the T-shirt, it's that cool). One scene in particular shows how amazing a director Kubrick is. Setting the scene – Jack finds himself at a lavish ball filled with society's upper crust; drinks are served and a waiter bumps into Torrance and makes a mess with the drink he is carrying. Jack recognises the waiter as Grady, the murderous caretaker, and confronts him on this issue. This gives birth to the immortal lines:
You were the caretaker here, Mr Grady…
I'm sorry to differ with you, Sir. But you were the caretaker. You have always been the caretaker. I ought to know. I have always been here.
No matter how many times I see this sequence, the scene sends shivers down my spine– not only is it an amazing display of Kubrick's showmanship, but these eighty or ninety seconds are definitely the zenith of Jack Nicholson's expansive career. However, this also goes to show how well The Shining has dated. For a twenty-eight year old film, Kubrick's horror swansong remains scarier than any of the tripe that has recently been made available.
The Shining also gave birth to stories of Kubrick's eccentricity – his obsessive attention to detail (to the point where supposed mistakes, in a Kubrick film, are often suspected to be intentional) resulted in this picture going down in the annals of motion picture history – the Guinness Book of World Records recognises The Shining as holding the record for the film with the most retakes per single scene, with the number standing at 127. Kubrick also gave Shelley Duvall a notorious belting for her diva-like behaviour (in her defence, she was the participant in those 127 cuts). Kubrick's rants and Duvall's pathetic, whiny bitchery can be seen in Vivian Kubrick's making-of that is reviewed in the Special Features section of this page.
In 1997, King collaborated with his cinematic partner-in-crime Mick Garris to realise his baby in more faithful form. The result was a four-part miniseries starring Steven Weber as Torrance and Rebecca De Mornay as Wendy. The entire thing was a bit of a bumble-fuck and, while it kept close to its source material, rarely did the King/Garris collaboration result in anything original and fresh. Garris lazily shambled through the proceedings, and it looks and smells cheap. This certainly hasn't stopped the cretinous King-adoring groups from lauding this as superior to Kubrick's 1980 adaptation, a claim that is nothing short of criminal.
I really can't think of anything negative to say about The Shining, as a horror film and a work of cinema. If you don't like this, there is seriously something wrong with you. And that's my objective opinion. |
We're obviously not on the same page. I think once Nicholson embarks on his stylised silliness, he sabotages every scene he's in. Importantly, the short doco/interview extra includes Spielberg saying the same thing - although 'The Shining' is one of his favourite films.
There are absolutely haunting moments, but Nicholson's camp (forever enshrined in pop. culture) just sounds the wrong note. I think the book IS better...
The movie might be missing lots of stuff from the novel, but the film adds a ton of its own meat via Kubrick. See the mini-series version to experience how dull a literal adpatation can be. This is what Kubrick knew would happen, and therefore took steps to avoid it in his version.