Home Room (2003)
By: Paul Ryan on July 25, 2006.
Share
1 Comments |
 |
| Peacock Films (Australia). All Regions, PAL. 1.78:1 (16:9 enhanced). English DD 2.0. 87 minutes |
| The Movie |
| Cover Art |
 |
| Credits |
Director: Uwe Boll
Starring: Jurgen Prochnow,
Kett Turton, Michael Belyea, Clint Howard, Michael
Pare, Elisabeth Rosen
Screenplay: Robert Dean
Klein
Music: Reinhard Besser
Tagline: Violent Lesson...
Deadly Learning
Country: Canada / Germany
AKA: Heart of America |
I honestly feel sorry for Uwe Boll. It's
doubtful that there has been another director in
this world who has been quite so vituperated against.
Sure, he may have churned out some less-than-great
adaptations of video games in the past few years,
but the level of venom directed at the man would
make you think he'd run over the dogs of every
movie blogger and videogame fan on the planet. This
said, House of the Dead and Alone
in the Dark were pretty bad. But
before you write Dr. Boll off entirely, you might
- just might - want to give this little-known opus
a look.
It's the start of the last day of school
at Riverside High, run by the fatherly Principal
Lewis (Jurgen Prochnow) and teachers and students
are rolling in to campus. Both the teachers and
the student body have their share of hard workers
and slackers. On this big day, the students are
preparing to say goodbye to one phase of their
lives and welcome the responsibilities of the
adult world. Two of the students, Daniel (Kett
Turton) and Barry (Michael Belya) have their own
goodbye planned for the school. Having been brutalized
for years by a gang of bullies led by stoner Ricky
(Brendan Fletcher), the pair are plotting a murderous
payback, to be delivered during their final Home
Room class…
Yes, it's an Uwe Boll message film. Bolling
For Columbine anyone?
Sorry. Couldn't resist…
Home Room is not a great film
by any means, but it isn't an especially
bad one either. After a wobbly start utilizing
statistics on American school violence (complete
with an inappropriate voiceover that tells us
what we are already reading, ala Boll's Alone in the Dark) the film settles
into a watchable, if superficial, look at high
school brutality. The cast, for the most part,
is quite good, even if the casting is occasionally
questionable (Michael Pare as an English teacher?)
and the students are mostly made up of the usual
22-year-old movie teenagers. The characters are
simply drawn, though the actors (especially Brendan
Fletcher as head bully Ricky and Clint Howard
as Daniel's abusive father) do go a long
way to giving them more depth than the script
allows. Where the film falls apart is at the climactic
massacre. It's too short and too rushed,
as if the filmmakers were straining to wrap things
up quickly. There's not enough time given
to reflection by the characters or much of a believable
aftermath. Instead, we get more clumsy statistics
about real-life shootings (yes, even Columbine),
delivered with that same needless voiceover.
A shame really, because this film shows that
Boll is capable of more as a filmmaker. Maybe
if he steered away from videogame adaptations
and concentrated on other genres, his reputation
might yet improve. Because I'm a sucker
for an underdog, I'll keep hoping. |
| Video |
| While the cover states that this disc is in 4x3,
the film is presented in a 1.78:1 ratio, enhanced
for widescreen sets. I noticed some mild pixelation
at times, but otherwise this is a decent transfer,
with solid colors and detail. However I did have
trouble with the disc itself. It refused to play
at all on the first player I tried it on and skipped
the menu system entirely on another. I'm not
sure if this was a pressing error or a glitch with
my equipment, but I can say the problem was quite
annoying. |
| Audio |
| Dolby 2.0 Stereo is on offer here. No complaints
here. Dialogue is constantly easy to understand
and Rienhard Besser's often overbearing
music score comes through loud and clear. |
| Extra Features |
| Nothing relating to the film itself, though
you do get three trailers for other Flashback/Peacock
releases which automatically run when you press
"play movie" on the main menu. Scary
Godmother: Some cgi-animated kiddie thing.
Bah, humbug. Small Miracles:
A very British family film with Jonathan Pryce. Fugitives Run: A dire-looking
David Hasslehoff comedy whose highlight seems
to be the sight of the Hoff electrocuting himself. |
| The Verdict |
| Home Room: The Heart of America shows that the much-maligned Uwe Boll is capable
of better things than his detractors give him credit
for. While flawed, it is watchable, and worth a
look. Flashback's budget DVD presentation
is serviceable, especially considering that it is
going as low as three dollars at some retailers.
Hopefully you just won't have the problems
with the disc that I did! |
|
| User Comments |
 |
1 user comments have been posted so far |
|
| |
 |