The Ring 2 (2005)
By: J.R. McNamara on August 5, 2005.
Share
0 Comments |
 |
| Universal (Australia). Region 2 & 4 PAL. 1.85:1 (16:9 enhanced). English DD 5.1. English (FHI) Subtitles. 105 mins |
| The Movie |
| Cover Art |
 |
| Credits |
Director: Hideo Nakata
Starring: Naomi Watts,
Simon Baker, David Dorfman, Elizabeth Perkins,
Gary Cole, Sissy Spacek
Screenplay: Ehren Kruger
Country:USA |
I remember years ago when I first heard the term
'sequel-itis', I took it as a good thing.
I mean, I love the Friday the 13th movies,
the Evil Dead movies, where would Star Wars be without Empire, The
Godfather without Godfather 2 and imagine a world without Dawn of the
Dead...
While watching The Ring 2 however,
I realized something. Sequel-itis is a bad thing.
It is a disease, a scourge, and this film suffers
from it, badly. Sometimes it is better to leave
a good story alone, and only make a sequel if
you have another story to tell.
Six months after the events of The Ring, Rachael Keller (Naomi Watts) and her son, Aiden
(David Dorfman) have decided to leave the bad
memories of the city behind and move to the quiet
town of Astoria. Rachael, through her connections
at the Astoria newspaper, hears of a teen death
with familiar circumstances, involving a mysterious
videotape. Soon Rachael, David and her boss Max
(Simon Baker) are involved in a life or death
struggle with the vengeful Samara (Kelly Stables)
who can escape the confines of her video prison
to wreak havoc on their lives.
The first Ring was a great example of how a film
from another culture, in this case J-horror, can
translate well into the Western ideology. Unfortunately, The Ring 2 comes off as horror-lite.
Sure it has some creepy set-pieces, but that's
all they are, set ups with no pay off. David Dorfman's
Aiden takes the lead in this film, but alas, he
is suffering from the same thing that all young
stars suffer from. When you are a kid, it is easy
to play a kid, but when you are a kid playing
something more than a kid, it requires acting
skill that in most cases is beyond the abilities
of their experience. This is no slight on Dorfman,
as he has a hard role in this film that he struggles
to pull off. The other roles are wasted as well.
Actors like Sissy Spacek (Carrie),
Gary Cole (American Gothic) and
Elizabeth Perkins (Crazy in Alabama)
are thrown away and the normally great Simon Baker
(Land of the Dead) is so generic
and bland that he could have been played by a
piece of bread. I must add though, that Naomi
Watts' presence, as always, is a delight.
I had great expectations of this film from its
choice of director, Hideo Nakata, who directed
the Japanese Ringu and Dark
Water. I imagined it would have great
acting and atmosphere, instead it felt forced
and deliberate. For my liking, Samara is seen
far too much, and Dorfman's black-eyed,
white skinned make-up is far too obvious. Maybe
the Japanese surroundings add to the uneasiness
of Nakata's J-horror films, with it being
an alien environment, but that does not come across
in an English speaking world. |
| Video |
| This movie is filmed in a majority of dull blues,
greens, grays and blacks. This completely sets the
tone of the movie and the image is perfect at all
times. I was really impressed with how such a limited
palette could look so deep. |
| Audio |
| Average 5.1 Surround. A movie with the subtleties
of The Ring 2 does not require the great big booms
required in an action film. This is a ghost story
and the soundtrack reflects this, not bad, but nothing
special either. The extras are all in 2.0. |
| Extra Features |
| The first of the Special Features is a short
film called 'Rings'. This short was
first seen as an extra on The Ring Collector's
Edition. This is the tale of the mysterious tape
that bridges the gap between The Ring and The
Ring 2, and includes daredevil teens that see
how long they can last before they have to copy
it and show it to someone else to save their own
lives. It's fairly well acted and has a
nice 'Ring' to it.
Next are three, 2 minute-10 second mini-documentaries
made to promote the film. The first, 'Imagination
in Focus' concentrates on Hideo Nakata,
and the impression he has left on both the Ring
movies (Asian and Western) and his co-workers.
The second, 'Samara – From Eye to
Icon' talks about the development of the
look of Samara without actually going too far
into the make-up effects. The third, 'The
Haunting of the Ring 2' is a ridiculous
fluff piece about the haunted happening on the
set and on location.
'HBO First Look: the Making of Ring 2'
is a 13 minute piece showing an abbreviated look
at the making of The Ring 2. Don't expect
some amazing extravaganza describing the intricacies
of special effects in the new millennium, this
is a by the numbers documentary for the average
movie goer, not the genre fan.
The Deleted and Alternate scenes are just that.
Usually when I see these sorts of things I wonder
why they were taken out, but these are evident,
they would have made the film annoying as well
as bad.
The is also a preview for Wes Craven's
new film Red Eye, which stars
Cillian Murphy (28 Days Later) and Rachael McAdams
(Mean Girls). |
| The Verdict |
| Unfortunately, The Ring now represents a new curse:
the curse of wasted talent. It amazes me how the
combined talents of Watts, Baker, Spacek, Perkins,
Nakata and writer Ehren Kruger could have been shattered
into the broken mess of The Ring 2.
Several excellent set-ups seem to fizzle out or
not reach their potential. This should have been
excellent, but there seems to be something absent.
What a shame. |
|
| User Comments |
 |
0 user comments have been posted so far |
|
| |
 |